|
Engaging high school students in the analysis of the
events that began on September 11th will contribute to the
broader effort to educate citizens so that they will be
committed to active engagement in the democratic process. It
also provides them with the tools to examine critically the
controversial issues of our day.
Using the challenging essays in the SSRC collection to teach
about these issues can fulfill the performance standards and
competencies that have been set for history and social
studies (especially at the Advanced Placement level). Some
of the skills this teaching resource aims to develop are:
-
reading comprehension
-
extrapolation (articulated in oral or written form) of main
points from written sources
-
critical analysis (articulated in written or oral form) of
primary and secondary sources for internal consistency and
logic (and where appropriate accuracy)
-
comparisons (for similarities and differences) of
alternative perspectives, and changes over time
-
development and articulation (in written and oral form) of
a sustained arguments for a given perspective
Content Standards met by Teaching about September 11 and
its Aftermath with the SSRC Essay Collection
We have reviewed the Curriculum Standards on the Social
Studies
(NCSS)
and the standards of many specific disciplines within the
social studies, i.e.,
McRel
and the College
Board's Advanced Placement Program, to offer some ideas
of the ways in which the subject areas included in this
teaching resource relate to curriculum requirements. While
all six subject areas relate in some way or another to most
social studies classes, below are some examples of the more
striking linkages between standard curricula and these
essays. These charts are therefore not exhaustive, and
are intended mainly for illustrative purposes.
- History (General Performance /
Cognitive Standards) Grades 9-12
- U.S. History
- A.P. American History
- World History
- A.P. World History
- Civics / Government
- A.P. United States Government
and Politics
- Economics
- Geography (World)
- World Cultures
1. HISTORY (GENERAL PERFORMANCE / COGNITIVE
STANDARDS) GRADES 9-12
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
In accordance with the National Standards for
U.S. History (1995), developed by the National Center
for History in the Schools
-
Under "Understands and knows how to analyze
chronological relationships and pattern":
-
Studying Globalization, New World Order? and New War?
can help students to:
-
understand historical continuity and change related
to a particular development of theme (e.g. development
of globalization)
-
Under "Understands the historical perspective":
-
Studying the Fundamentalism(s) subject area can help
students to:
-
analyze the values held by specific people who
influenced history and the role of their values played
in influencing history.
-
Reading the SSRC essays about New War?, New World
Order?, and Building Peace can help students to:
-
analyze the effects specific decisions had on
history ad studies how things might have been different
in absence of those decisions.
-
All six teaching resource subject areas can help students
to:
-
evaluate the validity and credibility of different
historical interpretations.
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
|
In accordance with Curriculum Standards for the Social
Studies: Expectations for Excellence (1994)
-
I. Time, Continuity and Change:
-
The Globalization, New Word Order?, New War?, and
Fundamentalism(s) subject areas address the directive:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of the ways human beings
view themselves in and over time.
-
V. Individuals Groups, and Institutions:
-
The Globalization, New World Order?, Fundamentalism(s),
Terrorism and Democratic Virtues and Building Peace
subject areas address:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of interactions among
individuals, groups, and institutions.
-
VI. Power, Authority, and Governance:
-
The Globalization, New World Order?, Fundamentalism(s),
Terrorism and Democratic Virtues & Building Peace
subject areas address:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences that
provide for the study of how people create and change
structures of power, authority, and governance.
-
VIII. Science, Technology, and Society
-
The Globalization, New World Order? & New War? subject
areas address:
-
Social Studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of relationships among
science, technology, and science.
-
IX Global Connections
-
The Globalization, New World Order?, Fundamentalism(s),
New War?, Terrorism and Democratic Virtues & Building
Peace subject areas address: Social Studies Programs
should include experiences that provide for the study
of global connections and interdependence
-
Social Studies Programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of global connections and
interdependence
|
2. U.S. HISTORY
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
In accordance with the National Standards for
U.S. History (1995) developed by the National Center
for History in the Schools
-
The New War?, New World Order?, Building Peace,
Terrorism and Democratic Virtues subject areas address
the requirement that the student:
-
Understands how the causes of and course of World War
II, the character of the war at home and abroad, and
its reshaping of the U.S. role in world affairs.
Understands how the Cold War and conflicts in Korea
and Vietnam influenced domestic and international
politics.
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
See History Grades 9-12
above.
|
3. A.P. AMERICAN HISTORY
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
Based on the
AP
American History Course Description prepared by
the College Board
-
All subject areas, especially New World Order? and New
War? address:
-
U.S. foreign policy and its changing relationship to
the World in the post-World War II era (Cold War)
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
See History Grades 9-12
above.
|
4. WORLD HISTORY
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
-
The New World Order?, Globalization, New War? subject
areas address the requirement that students:
-
Understand how post-World War II reconstruction
occurred, new international power relations took shape,
and colonial empires broke up.
-
The Globalization, New World Order?, Fundamentalism(s)
subject areas address the requirement that students:
-
Understand major global trends since World War II.
-
All six subject areas covered in this resource address
requirement that students:
-
Understand the search for community, stability, and
peace in an interdependent world.
-
Understand long-term changes and recurring patterns
in world history.
|
5. A.P. WORLD HISTORY
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
Based on the
AP
World History Course Description prepared by the
College Board
A.P. World History highlights six overarching themes.
Of the following six themes the following demand attention
to Globalization and New World Order?:
-
Impact of interaction among major societies
(trade, systems of international exchange, war,
and diplomacy).
-
The impact of change and continuity across the world
history periods covered by this course.
-
Impact of technology and demography on people and the
environment (population growth and decline, disease,
manufacturing, migrations, agriculture, weaponry).
-
Cultural and intellectual developments and
interactions among and within societies.
Specific standards, 1914 - Present:
-
The Globalization subject area addresses:
-
Impact of major global economic developments(Great
Depression; technology; Pacific Rim, multinational
corporations)
-
The New World Order?, New War?, Globalization, Building
Peace subject areas address:
-
New forces of revolution and other sources of
political innovation.
-
The Globalization, Fundamentalism(s), Terrorism and
Democratic Virtues, Building Peace subject areas address:
-
Internationalization of culture and reactions:
-
developments in global and regional cultures
-
interactions between elite and popular culture and
art
-
global cultural forces and patterns of resistance
(consumer culture; religious responses.
-
The Fundamentalism(s), Globalization, New World
Order? subject areas apply to:
-
Diverse interpretations:
-
Is cultural convergence or diversity the best model
for understanding increased intercultural contact in
the 21st century?
-
What are the advantages and disadvantages of using
units of analysis in the 20th century such as the
nation, the West, and the Third World?
-
Compare the impacts of Western consumer society on
two civilizations outside of Europe.
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
See History Grades 9-12
above.
|
6. CIVICS / GOVERNMENT
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
In accordance with the National Standards for Civics
and Government (1994) Prepared by The Center for Civics
Education
-
The Terrorism and Democratic Virtues subject areas can
help students to gain competency in the following:
-
Understanding the importance of sharing and supporting
certain values, beliefs and principles of American
constitutional democracy.
-
Understanding the role of diversity in American life and
the importance of shared values, political beliefs and
civic belief in an increasingly diverse American society.
-
Understanding the role and importance of law in the
American constitutional system and issues regarding
the judicial projection of individual rights.
-
The Terrorism and Democratic Virtues, Globalization,
New World Order?, New War?, and Building Peace subject
areas can help students to:
-
Understand what is meant by "the public agenda,"
how it is set, and how it is influenced by public
opinion and the media.
Understand the formation and implementation of
public policy.
Understand how the world is organized politically
into nation-states, how nation-states interact with
one another, and issues surrounding U.S. foreign
policy.
Understands the impact of significant political
and non-political developments of the United States
and other nations.
Understands issues regarding personal, political,
and economic rights.
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
In accordance with Curriculum Standards for the Social
Studies: Expectations for Excellence (1994)
-
VI. Power, Authority, and Governance:
-
The subject areas of Globalization, New World Order?,
Fundamentalism(s), Terrorism and Democratic Virtues &
Building Peace relate to the following:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of how people create and
change structures of power, authority, and governance.
-
IX. Global Connections
-
Subject areas Globalization, New World Order?, New War?,
Fundamentalism(s), Terrorism and Democratic Virtues &
Building Peace relate to:
-
Social Studies Programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of global connections and
interdependence.
-
X. Civic Ideals and Practices
-
Relevant to the SSRC subject areas of Terorrism and
Democratic Virtues, Fundamentalism(s), Building Peace:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of ideals, principles, and
practices of citizenship in a democratic republic.
|
7. A.P. UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT AND
POLITICS
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
The Terrorism and Democratic Virtues, Globalization, New
World Order?, New War?, and Building Peace subject areas
can help students to gain competency in the following:
-
Theories of democratic government
-
The impact of the mass media on politics
-
Public Policy
-
The formation of public policy
Extracted from
AP
Civics and U.S. Government Course Description
prepared by the College Board
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
(NA)
|
8. ECONOMICS
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
Based on the Voluntary National Content Standards
in Economics (1997) prepared by the National Council on
Economic Education
The Globalization and New World Order? subject areas
can help students to gain competency in the following:
-
Understand basic features of market structures and
exchanges.
-
Understand the roles governments play in national
economies.
-
Understand basic concepts about international
economics.
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
In accordance with Curriculum Standards for the Social
Studies: Expectations for Excellence (1994)
-
VI. Power, Authority, and Governance:
-
Relevant to the subject areas of Globalization, New World
Order?, Fundamentalism(s), Terrorism & Democratic Virtues,
and Building Peace:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of how people create
and change structures of power, authority, and
governance.
-
VII. Production, Distribution, and Consumption:
-
Relevant to the subject areas of Globalization and New
World Order?:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of how people organize
production, distribution, and consumption of goods
and services.
-
IX. Global Connections
-
Relevant to the subject areas of Globalization, New
World Order?, New War?, Fundamentalism(s), Terrorism
and Democratic Virtues, Building Peace
-
Social Studies Programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of global connections and
interdependence.
-
Extracted from Curriculum Standards for the Social
Studies: Expectations for Excellence (1994)
|
9. GEOGRAPHY (WORLD)
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
Based on the Geography for Life: National Geography
Standards (1994) prepared by The Geography Education
Standards Project
-
The Globalization, New World Order?, and Building Peace
subject areas can help students to gain competency in
the following areas:
-
The World in Spatial Terms
-
Knows location of places, geographic features,
and patterns of the environment.
-
Places and Regions
-
Understands that culture and experience influence
people's perceptions of places and regions.
-
Human Systems
-
Understands the nature and complexity of Earth's
cultural mosaics.
Understands the patterns and networks of economic
interdependence on the Earth's surface.
Understands the forces of cooperation and conflict
that shape the divisions of the Earth's surface.
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
In accordance with Curriculum Standards for the Social
Studies: Expectations for Excellence (1994)
-
III. People, Places, and Environment:
-
Relevant to the subject areas of Globalization and New
World Order?:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of people, places, and
environments.
-
VI. Power, Authority, and Governance:
-
Relevant to the subject areas of Globalization, New World
Order?, Fundamentalism(s), Terrorism & Democratic Virtues,
and Building Peace
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of how people create
and change structures of power, authority, and
governance.
-
VII. Production, Distribution, and Consumption:
-
Relevant to the subject areas of Globalization and New
World Order?
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of how people organize
production, distribution, and consumption of goods
and services.
-
IX. Global Connections
-
Relevant to the subject areas of Globalization, New
World Order?, New War?, Fundamentalism(s), Terrorism
and Democratic Virtues and Building Peace
-
Social Studies Programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of global connections and
interdependence.
|
10. WORLD CULTURES
|
Examples of how resource subject areas relate to
curricula and content standards
|
|
Please Note that since there is no academic discipline
that corresponds with world cultures, besides the National
Council for the Social Studies, no disciplinary association
has taken responsibility for developing specific guidelines
for the teaching of world cultures.
|
|
Examples of how subject areas relate to standards set
by National Council for the Social Studies
|
In accordance with Curriculum Standards for the Social
Studies: Expectations for Excellence (1994)
-
Relating to all subject areas:
-
I. Culture:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide fo rthe study of culture and culture
diversity.
-
II. Time, Continuity and Change:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of the ways human beings
view themselves in and over time.
-
IV. Individual Development and Identity:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of individual development
and identity.
-
V. Individuals Groups, and Institutions:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of interactions among
individuals, groups, and institutions.
-
VI. Power, Authority, and Governance:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of how people create and
change structures of power, authority, and
governance.
-
VII. Production, Distribution, and Consumption:
-
Social studies programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of how people organize
production, distribution, and consumption of goods
and services.
-
IX. Global Connections
-
Social Studies Programs should include experiences
that provide for the study of global connections and
interdependence.
|
Curriculum Standards on the Social Studies (NCSS) can be
accessed at:
http://www.socialstudies.org/standards/toc.html.
Many of these standards, including those for history, civics,
geography, and economics, are available on the website of
McRel, Mid-Continent Research for Education and Learning can
be accessed at:
http://www.mcrel.org/standards-benchmarks/.
Advanced Placement guidelines can be accessed at:
http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/courses.
|