Frontiers in Social Science features new research in the flagship journals of the Social Science Research Council’s founding disciplinary associations. Every month we publish a new selection of articles from the most recent issues of these journals, marking the rapid advance of the frontiers of social and behavioral science.

A method to measure context-specific word usage 

A new method to measure how words are used differently in different contexts works well even with few documents.

Author(s)
Pedro L. Rodriguez , Arthur Spirling, and Brandon M. Stewart
Journal
American Political Science Review
Citation
RODRIGUEZ, PEDRO L., ARTHUR SPIRLING, and BRANDON M. STEWART. "Embedding Regression: Models for Context-Specific Description and Inference." American Political Science Review 117.4 (2023): 1255-274. Print. Copy
Abstract

Social scientists commonly seek to make statements about how word use varies over circumstances—including time, partisan identity, or some other document-level covariate. For example, researchers might wish to know how Republicans and Democrats diverge in their understanding of the term “immigration.” Building on the success of pretrained language models, we introduce the à la carte on text (conText) embedding regression model for this purpose. This fast and simple method produces valid vector representations of how words are used—and thus what words “mean”—in different contexts. We show that it outperforms slower, more complicated alternatives and works well even with very few documents. The model also allows for hypothesis testing and statements about statistical significance. We demonstrate that it can be used for a broad range of important tasks, including understanding US polarization, historical legislative development, and sentiment detection. We provide open-source software for fitting the model.

Having younger siblings associated with lower test scores

30 years of data collected from the biological children of women in the National Longitudinal Study of Youth 1979 indicate that cognitive test scores are lower for first- and second-born children with younger siblings.

Author(s)
Wei-hsin Yu and Hope Xu Yan
Journal
American Sociological Review
Citation
Yu, W., & Yan, H. X. (2023). Effects of Siblings on Cognitive and Sociobehavioral Development: Ongoing Debates and New Theoretical Insights. American Sociological Review, 88(6), 1002-1030. https://doi.org/10.1177/00031224231210258 Copy
Abstract

Despite social scientists’ long-standing interest in the influences of siblings, previous research has not settled the debates on how relevant sibship size is to child development and whether growing up with more siblings could be beneficial. Using 30 years of longitudinal data and fixed-effects models, this study offers the most comprehensive evidence on how sibship size is tied to cognitive and sociobehavioral development. We also advance the literature by systematically comparing the consequences of gaining a sibling for children with varying ordinal positions. Contrary to prior studies using selective data from limited observation spans, we find that children experience net decreases in cognitive test scores as their family size grows. At the same time, our analysis shows that sibling additions are only important to first- and second-born children’s—not later-born children’s—cognitive development. Even for the first- and second-born, the marginal effect of adding a sibling lessens with each addition. Our results thus demonstrate the time-dependent nature of family resource-dilution processes. For sociobehavioral development, the evidence indicates that having an older sibling is beneficial, but gaining a younger sibling increases behavioral problems for some (e.g., first-born children). Because more children from large families have older siblings, children from larger families exhibit less problematic behavior, on average. By uncovering the complex relationship between siblings and noncognitive development, this study also generally contributes to the sociology of family and inequality.

A method to link records across datasets and detect duplicates

A new method to link records across datafiles and to detect duplicate records within files leverages a Bayesian approach incorporating prior information about the data collection processes of the datafiles in a flexible manner.

Author(s)
Serge Aleshin-Guendel and Mauricio Sadinle
Journal
Journal of the American Statistical Association
Citation
Serge Aleshin-Guendel & Mauricio Sadinle (2023) Multifile Partitioning for Record Linkage and Duplicate Detection, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 118:543, 1786-1795, DOI: 10.1080/01621459.2021.2013242 Copy
Abstract

Merging datafiles containing information on overlapping sets of entities is a challenging task in the absence of unique identifiers, and is further complicated when some entities are duplicated in the datafiles. Most approaches to this problem have focused on linking two files assumed to be free of duplicates, or on detecting which records in a single file are duplicates. However, it is common in practice to encounter scenarios that fit somewhere in between or beyond these two settings. We propose a Bayesian approach for the general setting of multifile record linkage and duplicate detection. We use a novel partition representation to propose a structured prior for partitions that can incorporate prior information about the data collection processes of the datafiles in a flexible manner, and extend previous models for comparison data to accommodate the multifile setting. We also introduce a family of loss functions to derive Bayes estimates of partitions that allow uncertain portions of the partitions to be left unresolved. The performance of our proposed methodology is explored through extensive simulations. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.

In-kind transactions in illiquid settings

An informal economy of in-kind payments to subcontractors in the Albanian construction industry facilitated transactions in a setting with low liquidity and few formal banking services.

Author(s)
Smoki Musaraj
Journal
American Anthropologist
Citation
Musaraj, Smoki. 2023. “ Housing as asset and payment: Construction, speculation, and financialization at the European periphery.” American Anthropologist 125: 865–879. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13913 Copy
Abstract

Construction booms have dominated Albania's economy and politics since the late 1990s. These booms continued even during times of illiquidity. One of the sources of financing construction in Albania is the practice of klering (in-kind payments). In this practice, developers pay subcontractors in (future) apartments in exchange for materials and labor. I argue that, in klering transactions, housing serves as an asset and a means of payment. The practice of klering emerged at the interface of postcommunist transformations, neoliberal reforms, and the fetishization of housing as an asset of more durable and multifaceted economic and cultural value. While grounded in the local histories and values of housing, klering is made possible by a fuzzy property regime, systemic corruption, and widespread informality. At the same time, klering echoes other global patterns pertaining to housing, such as the rise of asset economy, financialization, and money laundering through real estate purchases. The klering economy echoes speculative logics and practices that are prevalent across and that link centers and peripheries, formal and informal markets. These economic logics generate uncertainty and ambiguity; they mobilize social networks and cultural imaginaries; and they thrive on and further reproduce deep social and economic inequalities.

Municipal bond financing as a civil rights strategy

During the US civil rights movement, movement leaders sought to put pressure on the municipal bond market as a means to lever indebted southern municipalities into eliminating racial segregation.

Author(s)
Destin Jenkins
Journal
The American Historical Review
Citation
Destin Jenkins, Breaking the Bonds of Segregation: Civil Rights Politics and the History of Modern Finance, The American Historical Review, Volume 128, Issue 4, December 2023, Pages 1643–1669, https://doi.org/10.1093/ahr/rhad480 Copy
Abstract

This article uncovers the financial knowledge and bond market campaigns of the paradigmatic non-violent revolution of the twentieth century—the civil rights movement. It builds on an interpretation made by the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) and the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) during the early 1960s: segregation was a national problem because it was financed through a network of bankers across the country who specialized in the business of debt; certified by prominent bond attorneys in New York City, Chicago, and elsewhere; and because investors from around the country collected tax-exempt interest payments from indebted southern segregated municipalities. By weaving the internal memos, protest ephemera, and legal strategies of civil rights activists together with the credit assessments, scheduled bond offerings, and perspectives of financiers, this article reconstructs the attempts to politicize bond market transactions and efforts to place the economic certainty of segregation in doubt. In so doing, it offers a fresh perspective on the so-called classic phase of the civil rights movement (1954–1965). More generally, it raises powerful questions about the dilemmas of investment-focused campaigns, and how finance capital compounds the difficulties of organizing against authoritarian regimes.

Inaccurate forecasts of societal change

Psychologists’ predictions of societal change during the pandemic were no more accurate than random chance or lay predictions, and accuracy did not improve with domain-specific expertise.

Author(s)
Cendri A. Hutcherson, Konstantyn Sharpinskyi, Michael E. W. Varnum, Amanda Rotella, Alexandra S. Wormley, Louis Tay, and Igor Grossmann
Journal
American Psychologist
Citation
Hutcherson, C. A., Sharpinskyi, K., Varnum, M. E. W., Rotella, A., Wormley, A. S., Tay, L., & Grossmann, I. (2023). On the accuracy, media representation, and public perception of psychological scientists’ judgments of societal change. American Psychologist, 78(8), 968–981. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0001151 Copy
Abstract

At the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, psychological scientists frequently made on-the-record predictions in public media about how individuals and society would change. Such predictions were often made outside these scientists’ areas of expertise, with justifications based on intuition, heuristics, and analogical reasoning (Study 1; N = 719 statements). How accurate are these kinds of judgments regarding societal change? In Study 2, we obtained predictions from scientists (N = 717) and lay Americans (N = 394) in Spring 2020 regarding the direction of change for a range of social and psychological phenomena. We compared them to objective data obtained at 6 months and 1 year. To further probe how experience impacts such judgments, 6 months later (Study 3), we obtained retrospective judgments of societal change for the same domains (Nscientists = 270; Nlaypeople = 411). Bayesian analysis suggested greater credibility of the null hypothesis that scientists’ judgments were at chance on average for both prospective and retrospective judgments. Moreover, neither domain-general expertise (i.e., judgmental accuracy of scientists compared to laypeople) nor self-identified domain-specific expertise improved accuracy. In a follow-up study on meta-accuracy (Study 4), we show that the public nevertheless expects psychological scientists to make more accurate predictions about individual and societal change compared to most other scientific disciplines, politicians, and nonscientists, and they prefer to follow their recommendations. These findings raise questions about the role psychological scientists could and should play in helping the public and policymakers plan for future events.

High school guidance counselors can improve student outcomes

In a quasi-random design, assignment to more effective high school guidance counselors increased graduation, college enrollment, and bachelor’s degree attainment, particularly for low-achieving and low-income students.

Author(s)
Christine Mulhern
Journal
American Economic Review
Citation
Mulhern, Christine. 2023. "Beyond Teachers: Estimating Individual School Counselors' Effects on Educational Attainment." American Economic Review, 113 (11): 2846-93. Copy
Abstract

Counselors are a common school resource for students navigating complicated and consequential education choices. I estimate counselors' causal effects using quasi-random assignment policies in Massachusetts. Counselors vary substantially in their effectiveness at increasing high school graduation and college attendance, selectivity, and persistence. Counselor effects on educational attainment are similar in magnitude to teacher effects, but they flow through improved information and assistance more than cognitive or noncognitive skill development. Counselor effectiveness is most important for low-income and low-achieving students, so improving access to effective counseling may be a promising way to increase educational attainment and close socioeconomic gaps in education.

Differential privacy with inferential validity 

The authors develop a data access system that protects sensitive information through a differential privacy algorithm while also ensuring inferential validity.

Author(s)
Georgina Evans, Gary King, Margaret Schwenzeier, and Ahbradeep Thakurta
Journal
American Political Science Review
Citation
EVANS, G., KING, G., SCHWENZFEIER, M., & THAKURTA, A. (2023). Statistically Valid Inferences from Privacy-Protected Data. American Political Science Review, 117(4), 1275-1290. doi:10.1017/S0003055422001411 Copy
Abstract

Unprecedented quantities of data that could help social scientists understand and ameliorate the challenges of human society are presently locked away inside companies, governments, and other organizations, in part because of privacy concerns. We address this problem with a general-purpose data access and analysis system with mathematical guarantees of privacy for research subjects, and statistical validity guarantees for researchers seeking social science insights. We build on the standard of “differential privacy,” correct for biases induced by the privacy-preserving procedures, provide a proper accounting of uncertainty, and impose minimal constraints on the choice of statistical methods and quantities estimated. We illustrate by replicating key analyses from two recent published articles and show how we can obtain approximately the same substantive results while simultaneously protecting privacy. Our approach is simple to use and computationally efficient; we also offer open-source software that implements all our methods.

Developing measures of disease stigma

In a sample of 4.7 million news articles published between 1980 to 2018, word embedding measures of stigma for 106 health conditions reveal that preventable conditions and infectious diseases are associated with the highest levels of stigma.

Author(s)
Rachel Kahn Best and Alina Arseniev-Koehler
Journal
American Sociological Review
Citation
Best, R. K., & Arseniev-Koehler, A. (2023). The Stigma of Diseases: Unequal Burden, Uneven Decline. American Sociological Review, 88(5), 938-969. https://doi.org/10.1177/00031224231197436 Copy
Abstract

Why are some diseases more stigmatized than others? And, has disease stigma declined over time? Answers to these questions have been hampered by a lack of comparable, longitudinal data. Using word embedding methods, we analyze 4.7 million news articles to create new measures of stigma for 106 health conditions from 1980 to 2018. Using mixed-effects regressions, we find that behavioral health conditions and preventable diseases attract the strongest connotations of immorality and negative personality traits, and infectious diseases are most marked by disgust. These results lend new empirical support to theories that norm enforcement and contagion avoidance drive disease stigma. Challenging existing theories, we find no evidence for a link between medicalization and stigma, and inconclusive evidence on the relationship between advocacy and stigma. Finally, we find that stigma has declined dramatically over time, but only for chronic physical illnesses. In the past four decades, disease stigma has transformed from a sea of negative connotations surrounding most diseases into two primary conduits of meaning: infectious diseases spark disgust, and behavioral health conditions cue negative stereotypes. These results show that cultural meanings are especially durable when they are anchored by interests, and that cultural changes intertwine in ways that only become visible through large-scale research.

Estimating causal spillover effects

A new method allows for causal estimates of treatment spillover effects in an instrumental variable design when spillovers in treatment take-up can be restricted by the analyst.

Author(s)
Gonzalo Vazquez-Bare
Journal
Journal of the American Statistical Association
Citation
Gonzalo Vazquez-Bare (2023) Causal Spillover Effects Using Instrumental Variables, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 118:543, 1911-1922, DOI: 10.1080/01621459.2021.2021920 Copy
Abstract

I set up a potential outcomes framework to analyze spillover effects using instrumental variables. I characterize the population compliance types in a setting in which spillovers can occur on both treatment take-up and outcomes, and provide conditions for identification of the marginal distribution of compliance types. I show that intention-to-treat (ITT) parameters aggregate multiple direct and spillover effects for different compliance types, and hence do not have a clear link to causally interpretable parameters. Moreover, rescaling ITT parameters by first-stage estimands generally recovers a weighted combination of average effects where the sum of weights is larger than one. I then analyze identification of causal direct and spillover effects under one-sided noncompliance, and show that causal effects can be estimated by 2SLS in this case. I illustrate the proposed methods using data from an experiment on social interactions and voting behavior. I also introduce an alternative assumption, independence of the peers’ types, that identifies parameters of interest under two-sided noncompliance by restricting the amount of heterogeneity in average potential outcomes. Supplementary material of this article will be available in online.