Frontiers in Social Science features new research in the flagship journals of the Social Science Research Council’s founding disciplinary associations. Every month we publish a new selection of articles from the most recent issues of these journals, marking the rapid advance of the frontiers of social and behavioral science.

Increasing methods training in anthropology

A survey of members of the American Anthropological Association reveals strong support for increasing graduate student training in research methods, including systematic ethnographic research and statistical analysis.

Author(s)
Rosalyn Negrón, Amber Wutich, H. Russell Bernard, Alexandra Brewis, Alissa Ruth, Katherine Mayfour, Barbara Piperata, Melissa Beresford, Cindi SturtzSreetharan, Pardis Mahdavi, Jessica Hardin, Rebecca Zarger, Krista Harper, James Holland Jones, Clarence C. Gravlee and Bryan Brayboy
Journal
American Anthropologist
Citation
Negrón, Rosalyn, Amber Wutich, H. Russell Bernard, Alexandra Brewis, Alissa Ruth, Katherine Mayfour, Barbara Piperata, Melissa Beresford, Cindi SturtzSreetharan, Pardis Mahdavi, Jessica Hardin, Rebecca Zarger, Krista Harper, James Holland Jones, Clarence C. Gravlee, and Bryan Brayboy. 2024. “ Ethnographic methods: Training norms and practices and the future of American anthropology.” American Anthropologist 126: 458–469. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13991 Copy
Abstract

American anthropology is engaged in significant self-reckonings that call for big changes to how anthropology is practiced. These include (1) recognizing and taking seriously the demands to decolonize the ways research is done, (2) addressing precarious employment in academic anthropology, and (3) creating a discipline better positioned to respond to urgent societal needs. A central role for ethnographic methods training is a thread that runs through each of these three reckonings. This article, written by a team of cultural, biocultural, and linguistic anthropologists, outlines key connections between ethnographic methods training and the challenges facing anthropology. We draw on insights from a large-scale survey of American Anthropological Association members to examine current ethnographic methods capabilities and training practices. Study findings are presented and explored to answer three guiding questions: To what extent do our current anthropological practices in ethnographic methods training serve to advance or undermine current calls for disciplinary change? To what extent do instructors themselves identify disconnects between their own practices and the need for innovation? And, finally, what can be done, and at what scale, to leverage ethnographic methods training to meet calls for disciplinary change?

Text analysis in historical research

Advances in the computational analysis of large bodies of text have created new opportunities in historical research.

Author(s)
Jo Guldi
Journal
The American Historical Review
Citation
Jo Guldi, The Revolution in Text Mining for Historical Analysis is Here, The American Historical Review, Volume 129, Issue 2, June 2024, Pages 519–543, https://doi.org/10.1093/ahr/rhae163 Copy
Abstract

We have known since Vico to think of written text and oral traditions as two systems of culture. Social historians have long treated the rise of literacy itself as an important index of modernity, although collectors of oral traditions have typically transcribed folk songs and oral stories into text. Modern historians track the appearance of different genres of writing, from parliamentary blue books to the newspaper to the novel to published transcripts of court cases, as an index of evolving institutions and markets. And knowledge of the way that these texts circulated—whether read aloud in the post office or debated on bulletin board systems on the early internet—is often a clue to important social structures. The knowledge accessible through text does not exhaust in any way the full repository of artifacts that historians use—which of course extends to the formats of texts; to visual and audio media, which may or may not combine graphics, video, or sound with text; to the record of the built and natural environment itself; and to demographic, price, and climate data sometimes measured in nontextual ways and stored in separate repositories. Despite innovation and a plurality of possible concerns, many of our points of entry into the past remain through text.

Anxiety and adaptive threat responses

Developing more effective treatments for anxiety disorders by understanding the adaptive behaviors and biological systems that evolved to defend organisms from threat.

Author(s)
Michael S. Fanselow and Ann N. Hoffman
Journal
American Psychologist
Citation
Fanselow, M. S., & Hoffman, A. N. (2024). Fear, defense, and emotion: A neuroethological understanding of the negative valence research domain criteria. American Psychologist, 79(5), 725–734. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0001354 Copy
Abstract

We describe the close correspondence between predatory imminence continuum theory (PICT) and the National Institute of Mental Health’s Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) for negative valence. RDoC’s negative valence constructs relate aversively motivated behavioral reactions to various levels of threat. PICT divides defensive responses into distinct modes that vary along a continuum of the psychological closeness of predatory threat. While there is a close correspondence between PICT modes and negative valence threat constructs, based on PICT, we describe some potential elaborations of RDoC constructs. Both have consonant views of fear and anxiety and provide explicit distinctions between these emotional states, relating them to specific defensive behaviors and functions. We describe recent data that causally implicate human subjective emotional states with amygdala activity, which is also critical for defensive behavior. We conclude that attention to neuroethological views of defense can advance our understanding of the etiology and treatment of anxiety and stress disorders.

Civil service reform improved postal delivery

Leveraging the staggered expansion of civil service reform across US cities after 1883, the reduction of political disruptions to bureaucratic careers reduced postal delivery errors and increased postal service productivity.

Author(s)
Abhay Aneja and Guo Xu
Journal
American Economic Review
Citation
Aneja, Abhay, and Guo Xu. 2024. "Strengthening State Capacity: Civil Service Reform and Public Sector Performance during the Gilded Age." American Economic Review, 114 (8): 2352–87. Copy
Abstract

We use newly digitized records from the post office to study the effects of strengthened state capacity between 1875 and 1901. Exploiting the implementation of the Pendleton Act—a landmark statute that shielded bureaucrats from political interference—across US cities over two waves, we find that civil service reform reduced postal delivery errors and increased productivity. These improvements were most pronounced during election years when the reform dampened bureaucratic turnover. We provide suggestive evidence that reformed cities witnessed declining local partisan newspapers. Separating politics from administration, therefore, not only improved state effectiveness but also weakened the role of local politics.

Racial group voting patterns across congressional districts

Large-scale survey data reveal that Black voters consistently supported Democratic candidates in 2016, while white and Hispanic voting patterns varied across congressional districts. 

Author(s)
Shiro Kuriwaki, Stephen Ansolabehere, Angelo Dagonel and Soichiro Yamauchi
Journal
American Political Science Review
Citation
AMA (American Medical Association) KURIWAKI S, ANSOLABEHERE S, DAGONEL A, YAMAUCHI S. The Geography of Racially Polarized Voting: Calibrating Surveys at the District Level. American Political Science Review. 2024;118(2):922-939. doi:10.1017/S0003055423000436 Copy
Abstract

Debates over racial voting, and over policies to combat vote dilution, turn on the extent to which groups’ voting preferences differ and vary across geography. We present the first study of racial voting patterns in every congressional district (CD) in the United States. Using large-sample surveys combined with aggregate demographic and election data, we find that national-level differences across racial groups explain 60% of the variation in district-level voting patterns, whereas geography explains 30%. Black voters consistently choose Democratic candidates across districts, whereas Hispanic and white voters’ preferences vary considerably across geography. Districts with the highest racial polarization are concentrated in the parts of the South and Midwest. Importantly, multiracial coalitions have become the norm: in most CDs, the winning majority requires support from non-white voters. In arriving at these conclusions, we make methodological innovations that improve the precision and accuracy when modeling sparse survey data.

Predicting the emergence of musical innovation

An analysis of ~25,000 Billboard Hot 100 songs between 1958 and 2016 reveals that the distribution of song features in an existing market shapes the emergence of musical innovation.

Author(s)
Khwan Kim and Noah Askin
Journal
American Sociological Review
Citation
Kim, K., & Askin, N. (2024). Feature-Based Structures of Opportunity: Genre Innovation in the American Popular Music Industry, 1958 to 2016. American Sociological Review, 89(3), 542-583. https://doi.org/10.1177/00031224241246271 Copy
Abstract

We offer a new perspective on how cultural markets are structured and the conditions under which innovations are more likely to emerge. We argue that in addition to organization- and producer-level factors, product features—the locus of marketplace interaction between producers and consumers—also structure markets. The aggregated distribution of product features helps producers gauge where to differentiate or conform and when consumers may be more receptive to the kind of novelty that spawns new genres, our measure of innovation. We test our arguments with a unique dataset comprising the nearly 25,000 songs that appeared on the Billboard Hot 100 chart from 1958 to 2016, using computational methods to capture and analyze the aesthetic (sonic) and semantic (lyrical) features of each song and, consequently, the market for popular music. Results reveal that new genres are more likely to appear following markets that can be characterized as diverse along one feature dimension while homogenous along the other. We then connect specific configurations of feature distributions to subsequent song novelty before linking the aesthetic and semantic novelty of individual songs to genre emergence. We replicate our findings using industry-wide data and conclude with implications for the study of markets and innovation.

Predicting property insurance claims

A deep learning model and high-frequency dynamic weather data can improve predictions of reported losses, leading to improved management of insurance claims.

Author(s)
Penh Shi, Wei Zhang and Kun Shi
Journal
Journal of the American Statistical Association
Citation
Shi, P., Zhang, W., & Shi, K. (2024). Leveraging Weather Dynamics in Insurance Claims Triage Using Deep Learning. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 119(546), 825–838. https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.2024.2308314 Copy
Abstract

In property insurance claims triage, insurers often use static information to assess the severity of a claim and to identify the subsequent actions. We hypothesize that the pattern of weather conditions throughout the course of a loss event is predictive of the insured losses, and hence appropriate use of weather dynamics improves the operation of insurers’ claim management. To test this hypothesis, we propose a deep learning method to incorporate dynamic weather information in the predictive modeling of the insured losses for reported claims. The proposed method features a hierarchical network architecture to address the challenges in claims triage due to the nature of weather dynamics. In the empirical analysis, we examine a portfolio of hail damage property insurance claims obtained from a major U.S. insurance carrier. When supplemented by dynamic weather information, the deep learning method exhibits substantial improvement in the hold-out predictive performance. We further design a cost-conscious decision strategy for triaging claims using the probabilistic forecasts of the insurance claim amounts. We show that leveraging weather dynamics in claims triage leads to a reduction of up to 9% and 6% in operational costs compared to when the triaging decision is based on forecasts without any weather information and with only static weather information, respectively. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.

Hindu politics in the Himalayas

An exploration of Hindu political life in the northwestern Himalayan region suggests that the invocation of religious beliefs can undergird anti-democratic politics.

Author(s)
Mona Bhan and Radhika Govindrajan
Journal
American Anthropologist
Citation
Bhan, Mona, and Radhika Govindrajan. 2024. “ More-than-human supremacy: Himalayan lessons on cosmopolitics.” American Anthropologist 126: 182–193. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13943 Copy
Abstract

How might our analysis of fascism be enriched if we turn our attention to how contemporary supremacist movements self-fashion themselves as more-than-human formations? How is fascist politics naturalized through claims that it is fueled by the agency and vitality of not just humans but also other-than-humans? How do right-wing supremacists’ assertions that theirs is an indigenous more-than-human politics that suffered but endured the violence of colonialism support the framing of fascism as a decolonizing project? In this article, we ground these questions in an ethnographic analysis of what we call the more-than-human turn in contemporary Hindu-supremacist politics in the northwestern Himalayan region, focusing specifically on two political projects: the Hindu right-wing's rediscovery of “ancient” Hindu rivers and communities in Ladakh and cow protection in Uttarakhand. In contrast to ontological anthropologists who suggest that cosmopolitics is plural and liberatory, we demonstrate how the inclusion of nonhuman entities in political life can serve to naturalize a fascist politics that seeks the extermination of those who are not part of the natural order of life. We urge anthropologists to make room for skepticism and critique in their analysis of cosmopolitical formations instead of prematurely celebrating “ecopolitics” as anti-Western and anticolonial.

Slavery in 19th century Iran

Archival records of the Iranian royal family during the 19th century provide insight into the history of modern slavery in Iran.

Author(s)
Leila Pourtavaf
Journal
The American Historical Review
Citation
Leila Pourtavaf, Gulistan in Black and White: The Racial and Gendered Legacies of Slavery in Nineteenth-Century Qajar Iran, The American Historical Review, Volume 129, Issue 2, June 2024, Pages 395–428, https://doi.org/10.1093/ahr/rhae152 Copy
Abstract

This paper takes the late Qajar court and harem as a historically specific site through which we can examine the complex and diverse histories of slavery within the region in the nineteenth century, as well as the ways in which hierarchies of race, gender, and sex functioned as constitutive elements of this institution. I examine a particular albeit very elite site, Nasir al-Din Shah’s harem, occupied by a variety of enslaved and formerly enslaved constituents who were a product of the evolving slave trade. The essay ends by zooming in on the lives (and afterlives) of two eunuchs, Aziz Khan and Agha Bahram, who were part of the servant class of Gulistan Palace during Nasir al-Din Shah’s reign, and whose life trajectories offer us some insight into the racial and gendered legacies of late nineteenth-century slavery in Iran.

Reducing inaccurate claims about inherited traits

Adopting scientific standards from the disciplines of genetics and evolutionary biology would reduce scientifically inaccurate claims in psychology journals about inherited traits.

Author(s)
Kevin A Bird, John P. Jackson Jr., and Andrew S. Winston
Journal
American Psychologist
Citation
Bird, K. A., Jackson, J. P., Jr., & Winston, A. S. (2024). Confronting scientific racism in psychology: Lessons from evolutionary biology and genetics. American Psychologist, 79(4), 497–508. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0001228 Copy
Abstract

Although the American Psychological Association has taken a strong antiracism stance, scientific racism continues to be published in psychology journals and scholarly books. Recent articles claim that the folk categories of race are genetically meaningful divisions and that evolved genetic differences among races and nations are important for explaining immutable differences in cognitive ability, educational attainment, crime, sexual behavior, and wealth; all claims that are opposed by a strong scientific consensus to the contrary. These claims remain a serious source of harm through the naturalization of inequality and through support for the work of racial extremists. Contemporary “racial hereditarian research” claims to rest on modern genetics and evolutionary biology and to draw on their methods, such as genome-wide association studies. These new arguments fail to meet the evidentiary and ethical standards of these disciplines for the study of human variation. If psychology adopted standards from genetics and evolutionary biology, the current racial hereditarian work would be ineligible for publication. Actions that the American Psychological Association can take to deal with scientific racism are described.