Frontiers in Social Science features new research in the flagship journals of the Social Science Research Council’s founding disciplinary associations. Every month we publish a new selection of articles from the most recent issues of these journals, marking the rapid advance of the frontiers of social and behavioral science.

Firms with highly-rated work environments hire fewer Black employees

Reviews from Indeed.com and firm-level data indicate that Black employees are underrepresented at highly-rated firms, particularly in areas with more conservative racial attitudes and more prevalent workplace racial discrimination.

Author(s)
Letian Zhang
Journal
American Sociological Review
Citation
Zhang, Letian. "Racial Inequality in Work Environments." American Sociological Review 88, no. 2 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1177/00031224231157303 Copy
Abstract

This article explores racial stratification in work environments. Inequality scholars have long identified racial disparities in wage and occupational attainment, but workers’ careers and well-being are also shaped by elements of their work environment, including firm culture, managerial style, and work-life balance. I theorize two processes that could lead to racial inequality in firms’ work environments: (1) employee sorting due to exclusionary practices, and (2) spillover from racial differences in occupation and geographic location. To test this, I gathered a unique firm-level dataset composed of one million employee reviews, covering most large and medium-sized firms in the United States. I show that firms with more Black employees score lower for managerial quality, firm culture, and work-life balance, and firms with more Asian employees score higher on these dimensions. However, Asian employees’ advantage disappears when controlling for occupation, industry, and geography, whereas Black employees’ disadvantage persists, suggesting that the process of firm-level employee sorting is at work. Consistent with this, I find that Black employees’ disadvantage is strongest in areas with more conservative racial attitudes and more prevalent workplace racial discrimination. I then replicated the main findings using two entirely different data sources. Together, these results underscore racial inequality in work environments, an overlooked but important dimension of workplace inequality.

New interpolation method used to estimate income segregation in the US

A latent density approach to interpolation improves on previous methods by accounting for uncertainty of model inputs, allowing researchers to construct income segregation indices from ACS tract-level distributions.

Author(s)
Matthew Simpson, Scott H. Holan, Christopher K. Wikle, and Jonathan R. Bradley
Journal
Journal of the American Statistical Association
Citation
Simpson, Matthew, Scott H. Holan, Christopher K. Wikle, and Jonathan R. Bradley. "Interpolating Population Distributions using Public-Use Data: An Application to Income Segregation using American Community Survey Data." Journal of the American Statistical Association 118, 541 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.2022.2126779 Copy
Abstract

The presence of income inequality is an important problem to demographers, policy makers, economists, and social scientists. A causal link has been hypothesized between income inequality and income segregation, which measures how much households with similar incomes cluster. The information theory index is used to measure income segregation, however, critics have suggested the divergence index instead. Motivated by this, we construct both indices using American Community Survey (ACS) estimates of features of the income distribution. Since the elimination of the decennial census long form, methods of computing these indices must be updated to interpolate ACS estimates and account for survey error. We propose a novel model-based method to do this which improves on previous approaches by using more types of estimates, and by providing uncertainty quantification. We apply this method to estimate U.S. census tract-level income distributions, and in turn use these to construct both income segregation indices. We find major differences between the two indices and find evidence that the information index underestimates the relationship between income inequality and income segregation. The literature suggests interventions designed to reduce income inequality by reducing income segregation, or vice versa, so using the information index implicitly understates the value of these interventions. Supplementary materials for this article, including a standardized description of the materials available for reproducing the work, are available as an online supplement.

West African women challenge gender norms through “tactical strangerhood”

Women working as foreign traders in Dakar use their status as strangers to their economic advantage.

Author(s)
Gunvor Jónsson
Journal
American Anthropologist
Citation
Jónsson, Gunvor. "Tactical strangers: Mobility, trade, and gendered strangerhood in West Africa." American Anthropologist 125, no. 2 (2023): 298-309. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13835 Copy
Abstract

Mande women in West Africa unable or unwilling to conform to patriarchal gender expectations risk being evicted from social and kinship support structures. Some nonconformist women from Mali respond to this predicament by engaging in tactical strangerhood: they choose to remain on the social margins, capitalizing on their situation as strangers by working as foreign traders in Dakar (Senegal). Tactical strangerhood entails only partial inclusion into patriarchal family and social structures and constitutes one of the nonconformist ways in which women in West Africa enact gender roles. Long-distance trade and travel by Mande women have led to new forms of gendered strangerhood, challenging—and potentially transforming—dominant ideologies of gender differentiation in this part of West Africa. By engaging in tactical strangerhood, women develop new forms of gendered subjectivity. Tactical strangerhood can therefore be considered an implicitly feminist and emancipatory exercise.

Hay fueled US industrialization

A new analysis counters the King Cotton narrative and reveals that hay was just as valuable as cotton and wheat in the nineteenth-century US.

Author(s)
Ariel Ron
Journal
The American Historical Review
Citation
Ron, Ariel. "When Hay Was King: Energy History and Economic Nationalism in the Nineteenth-Century United States." The American Historical Review 128, no. 1 (March 2023): Pages 177–213. https://doi.org/10.1093/ahr/rhad009 Copy
Abstract

Hay was a linchpin of the early industrial energy regime. It was the primary fodder for working horses, who became more rather than less important over the 1800s. Though largely ignored by historians, hay was of comparable value to cotton and wheat in the nineteenth-century United States. The crop’s historiographical invisibility is partly due to its relatively informal and decidedly subglobal production and exchange patterns. Whereas cotton and wheat exports passed through customhouses and institutionalized exchanges that carefully recorded trade volumes, hay was almost never exported and often underwent no market transaction at all, instead being used as an intermediate good on farms. Only when the US federal government added a detailed agricultural census in 1850 did the magnitude and importance of hay production become publicly legible. At that point, hay was drafted into a wide-ranging debate about economic development between Northern antislavery nationalists and Southern proslavery free traders, with “King Hay” emerging as a foil for “King Cotton.” King Hay thus urges historians to pay more attention to the trade patterns, developmental policies, and economic ideologies that generated distinctly national, as opposed to global, economic spaces within nineteenth-century capitalism.

Middle-income adults are at lowest risk for depression

A meta-analysis suggests that income is quadratically associated with depressive symptoms, especially among middle-aged adults and White individuals.

Author(s)
Kevin M. Korous, José M. Causadias, Robert H. Bradley, Roy Levy, Karina Cahill, Longfeng Li, and Suniya Luthar
Journal
American Psychologist
Citation
Korous, Kevin M., José M. Causadias, Robert H. Bradley, Roy Levy, Karina Cahill, Longfeng Li, and Suniya Luthar. '"More is better” or “better near the middle”? A U.S.-based individual participant data meta-analysis of socioeconomic status and depressive symptoms.' American Psychologist 78, no. 3 (2023): 305–320. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0001076 Copy
Abstract

Socioeconomic status (SES) is a widely researched construct in developmental science, yet less is known concerning relations between SES and adaptive behavior. Specifically, is the relation linear, with higher SES associated with better outcomes, or does the direction of association change at different levels of SES? Our aim was to examine linear (“more is better”) and quadratic (“better near the middle”) associations between components of SES (i.e., income, years of education, occupational status/prestige) and depressive symptoms (Center for Epidemiologic Studies–Depression Scale), and to explore moderation by developmental period (adolescence, young, middle, and older adulthood), gender/sex (female, male), and race/ethnicity (Asian American, Black, Latinx, multiracial, Native American, White). We hypothesized that there would be more support for a model containing quadratic associations. We conducted a two-stage meta-analytic structural equation model of 60 data sets (27,242 correlations, 498,179 participants) within the United States, accounting for dependencies between correlations, which were identified via the Interuniversity Consortium for Political and Social Research and handled using a two-step approach. Income was quadratically associated with depressive symptoms, but the quadratic model did not explain more variance in depressive symptoms than the linear model. Developmental period and race/ethnicity moderated the associations: Income was quadratically associated with depressive symptoms among middle-aged adults, and years of education were quadratically associated with depressive symptoms among White samples. Our findings suggest that researchers and clinical practitioners should consider the elevated risk of depressive symptoms for individuals from low and high-income backgrounds in the United States.

Banning gender preferences in job ads improves diversity

Results from a natural experiment illustrate that banning gender preferences in job ads increased women’s (men’s) share of callbacks to jobs that had requested men (women) by 61 (146) percent.

Author(s)
Peter Kuhn and Kailing Shen
Journal
American Economic Review
Citation
Kuhn, Peter, and Kailing Shen. "What Happens When Employers Can No Longer Discriminate in Job Ads?" American Economic Review 113, no. 4 (2023): 1013-48. DOI: 10.1257/aer.20211127. Copy
Abstract

When employers' explicit gender requests were unexpectedly removed from a Chinese job board overnight, pools of successful applicants became more integrated: women's (men's) share of callbacks to jobs that had requested men (women) rose by 61 (146) percent. The removal "worked" in this sense because it generated a large increase in gender-mismatched applications, and because those applications were treated surprisingly well by employers, suggesting that employers' gender requests often represented relatively weak preferences or outdated stereotypes. The job titles that were integrated by the ban, however, were not the most gendered ones, and were disproportionately lower-wage jobs.

Citizens often rationalize perceptions of democracy to tolerate undemocratic policies

Novel survey experiments in the U.S. and 22 democracies worldwide indicate that citizens often tolerate undemocratic policies that benefit them by convincing themselves that the policies are democratic, rather than deliberately rejecting democracy.

Author(s)
Suthan Krishnarajan
Journal
American Political Science Review
Citation
Krishnarajan, Suthan. “Rationalizing Democracy: The Perceptual Bias and (Un)Democratic Behavior.” American Political Science Review 117, no. 2 (2023): 474–96. doi:10.1017/S0003055422000806. Copy
Abstract

Democracy often confronts citizens with a dilemma: stand firm on democracy while losing out on policy or accept undemocratic behavior and gain politically. Existing literature demonstrates that citizens generally choose the latter—and that they do so deliberately. Yet there is an alternative possibility. Citizens can avoid this uncomfortable dilemma altogether by rationalizing their understandings of democracy. When a politician advances undesired policies without violating democratic rules and norms, people find ways to perceive the behavior as undemocratic. When a politician acts undemocratically to promote desired policies, citizens muster up arguments for considering it democratic. Original survey experiments in the United States, and 22 democracies worldwide, provide strong support for this argument. It is thus not deliberate acceptance, but a fundamentally different perceptual logic that drives the widespread approval of undemocratic behavior in today’s democracies.

College completion can reduce the Black-White earnings gap

Decomposition analysis of education and earnings suggests that interventions that both increase rates of college attendance and bachelor’s completion and close racial disparities in these rates can substantially reduce the Black-White earnings gap.

Author(s)
Xiang Zhou and Guanghui Pan
Journal
American Sociological Review
Citation
Zhou, Xiang and Guanghui Pan. "Higher Education and the Black-White Earnings Gap." American Sociological Review 88, no. 1 (2023): 154–188. https://doi.org/10.1177/00031224221141887 Copy
Abstract

How does higher education shape the Black-White earnings gap? It may help close the gap if Black youth benefit more from attending and completing college than do White youth. On the other hand, Black college-goers are less likely to complete college relative to White students, and this disparity in degree completion helps reproduce racial inequality. In this study, we use a novel causal decomposition and a debiased machine learning method to isolate, quantify, and explain the equalizing and stratifying roles of college. Analyzing data from the NLSY97, we find that a bachelor’s degree has a strong equalizing effect on earnings among men (albeit not among women); yet, at the population level, this equalizing effect is partly offset by unequal likelihoods of bachelor’s completion between Black and White students. Moreover, a bachelor’s degree narrows the male Black-White earnings gap not by reducing the influence of class background and pre-college academic ability, but by lessening the “unexplained” penalty of being Black in the labor market. To illuminate the policy implications of our findings, we estimate counterfactual earnings gaps under a series of stylized educational interventions. We find that interventions that both boost rates of college attendance and bachelor’s completion and close racial disparities in these transitions can substantially reduce the Black-White earnings gap.

Improving biomonitoring of environmental hazards

A new statistical approach improves detection of harmful environmental chemicals in pooled biomedical samples and reveals vulnerabilities among adolescent, senior, and low-income populations.

Author(s)
Yan Liua, Dewei Wang, Li Li, and Dingsheng Li
Journal
Journal of the American Statistical Association
Citation
Liua, Yan, Dewei Wang, Li Li, and Dingsheng Li. "Assessing Disparities in Americans’ Exposure to PCBs and PBDEs Based on NHANES Pooled Biomonitoring Data." Journal of the American Statistical Association (2023). https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.2023.2195546. Copy
Abstract

The National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) has been continuously biomonitoring Americans’ exposure to two families of harmful environmental chemicals: polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs). However, biomonitoring these chemicals is expensive. To save cost, in 2005, NHANES resorted to pooled biomonitoring; i.e., amalgamating individual specimens to form a pool and measuring chemical levels from pools. Despite being publicly available, these pooled data gain limited applications in health studies. Among the few studies using these data, racial/age disparities were detected, but there is no control for confounding effects. These disadvantages are due to the complexity of pooled measurements and a dearth of statistical tools. Herein, we developed a regression-based method to unzip pooled measurements, which facilitated a comprehensive assessment of disparities in exposure to these chemicals. We found increasing dependence of PCBs on age and income, whereas PBDEs were the highest among adolescents and seniors and were elevated among the low-income population. In addition, Hispanics had the lowest PCBs and PBDEs among all demographic groups after controlling for potential confounders. These findings can guide the development of population-specific interventions to promote environmental justice. Moreover, both chemical levels declined throughout the period, indicating the effectiveness of existing regulatory policies.

Chinese sugar production in Madagascar

A sugar plantation in northern Madagascar operated by a Chinese state-owned company illustrates the challenges of inclusive economic development.

Author(s)
Mingyuan Zhang
Journal
American Anthropologist
Citation
Zhang, Mingyuan. "Burn to Harvest, Burn to Sabotage: Between Fire and Water on a Sugar Plantation in Madagascar." American Anthropologist 125, no. 1 (2023): 100-111. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13811. Copy
Abstract

Since 2009, the Chinese state-owned corporation SINLANX has been managing the Anjava Sugar Plantation, previously managed by French, Malagasy, and Mauritian companies, in northern Madagascar. Built upon the infrastructure constructed by the French colonial regime and operating based on a collaboration agreement between SINLANX and the Malagasy state-owned sugar company, Anjava presents a telling story of spatialized acts of survival and racialized conflicts over land and water in the interstitial spaces between capitalist production and subsistence economy. Malagasy villagers’ access to resources is often squeezed by multiple enclosures: a water-delivery system and a land-distribution system that prioritize sugar production and a bureaucratic system that punishes those who transgress the enclosures. Although Anjava villagers take advantage of the rhythm of sugar harvests and the nature of fire to sabotage sugar production or to make water claims for their livelihood, the agrarian and infrastructural arrangements at Anjava have perpetuated conditions of chronic precarity and profound marginalization of a landless population. The struggles at Anjava must be contextualized in the complex and ambiguous spaces between capital and labor, livelihood and resistance, dominance and adaptation, and ethnic collaboration and hostility.