Frontiers in Social Science features new research in the flagship journals of the Social Science Research Council’s founding disciplinary associations. Every month we publish a new selection of articles from the most recent issues of these journals, marking the rapid advance of the frontiers of social and behavioral science.

Randomizing Court Fees

Randomizing court fees charged to misdemeanor defendants in Oklahoma County, Oklahoma reveals that court fees neither deter nor increase new crime, and produce little financial benefit for governments.

Author(s)
Devah Pager, Rebecca Goldstein, Helen Ho, and Bruce Western
Journal
American Sociological Review
Citation
Pager D, Goldstein R, Ho H, Western B. Criminalizing Poverty: The Consequences of Court Fees in a Randomized Experiment. American Sociological Review. 2022;87(3):529-553. doi:10.1177/00031224221075783 Copy
Abstract

Court-related fines and fees are widely levied on criminal defendants who are frequently poor and have little capacity to pay. Such financial obligations may produce a criminalization of poverty, where later court involvement results not from crime but from an inability to meet the financial burdens of the legal process. We test this hypothesis using a randomized controlled trial of court-related fee relief for misdemeanor defendants in Oklahoma County, Oklahoma. We find that relief from fees does not affect new criminal charges, convictions, or jail bookings after 12 months. However, control respondents were subject to debt collection efforts at significantly higher rates that involved new warrants, additional court debt, tax refund garnishment, and referral to a private debt collector. Despite significant efforts at debt collection among those in the control group, payments to the court totaled less than 5 percent of outstanding debt. The evidence indicates that court debt charged to indigent defendants neither caused nor deterred new crime, and the government obtained little financial benefit. Yet, fines and fees contributed to a criminalization of low-income defendants, placing them at risk of ongoing court involvement through new warrants and debt collection.

Pricing Earthquake Risk

In a quarterly panel dataset of real estate transaction prices for five Japanese cities over the period 2006–2015, earthquake risk is priced at an average –2.0% of log property prices, slightly more than the annual income of a middle-income Japanese household.

Author(s)
Masako Ikefuji, Roger J. A. Laeven, Jan R. Magnus, and Yuan Yue
Journal
Journal of the American Statistical Association
Citation
Masako Ikefuji, Roger J. A. Laeven, Jan R. Magnus & Yuan Yue (2022) Earthquake Risk Embedded in Property Prices: Evidence From Five Japanese Cities, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 117:537, 82-93, DOI: 10.1080/01621459.2021.1928512 Copy
Abstract

We analyze the impact of short-run (90 days) and long-run (30 years) earthquake risk on real estate transaction prices in five Japanese cities (Tokyo, Osaka, Nagoya, Fukuoka, and Sapporo), using quarterly data over the period 2006–2015. We exploit a rich panel dataset (331,343 observations) with property characteristics, ward attractiveness information, macroeconomic variables, and long-run seismic hazard data, supplemented with short-run earthquake probabilities generated from a seismic excitation model using historical earthquake occurrences. We design a hedonic property price model that allows for subjective probability weighting, employ a multivariate error components structure, and develop associated maximum likelihood estimation and variance computation procedures. Our approach enables us to identify the total compensation for earthquake risk embedded in property prices, to decompose this into pieces stemming from short-run and long-run risk, and to distinguish between objective and subjectively weighted (“distorted”) earthquake probabilities. We find that objective long-run earthquake probabilities have a statistically significant negative impact on property prices, whereas short-run earthquake probabilities become statistically significant only when we allow them to be distorted. The total compensation for earthquake risk amounts to an average –2.0% of log property prices, slightly more than the annual income of a middle-income Japanese household. Supplementary materials for this article, including a standardized description of the materials available for reproducing the work, are available as an online supplement.

Understanding Vaccine Hesitancy

A nationally representative survey finds that parents’ vaccination decisions are correlated with their beliefs about whether society is on their side.

Author(s)
Luke J. Matthews, Sarah A. Nowak, Courtney C. Gidengil, Christine Chen, Joseph M. Stubbersfield, Jamshid J. Tehrani, and Andrew M. Parker
Journal
American Anthropologist
Citation
Matthews, L. J., Nowak, S. A., Gidengil, C. C., Chen, C., Stubbersfield, J. M., Tehrani, J. J., and Parker, A. M.. 2022. “ Belief correlations with parental vaccine hesitancy: Results from a national survey.” American Anthropologist. 124: 291– 306. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13714 Copy
Abstract

We conducted a nationally representative survey of parents’ beliefs and self-reported behaviors regarding childhood vaccinations. Using Bayesian selection among multivariate models, we found that beliefs, even those without any vaccine or health content, predicted vaccine-hesitant behaviors better than demographics, social network effects, or scientific reasoning. The multivariate structure of beliefs combined many types of ideation that included concerns about both conspiracies and side effects. Although they are not strongly related to vaccine-hesitant behavior, demographics were key predictors of beliefs. Our results support some of the previously proposed pro-vaccination messaging strategies and suggest some new strategies not previously considered.

Financing Westward Expansion with Native Wealth

Native lands in the United States were purchased through federally-administered trust funds, enabling the use of Native wealth to finance the banks, canals, and railways that led to further Native dispossession.

Author(s)
Emilie Connolly
Journal
The American Historical Review
Citation
Emilie Connolly, Fiduciary Colonialism: Annuities and Native Dispossession in the Early United States, The American Historical Review, Volume 127, Issue 1, March 2022, Pages 223–253, https://doi.org/10.1093/ahr/rhac012 Copy
Abstract

Federal officials in the early United States built an empire by purchase. But rather than hand over lump sums for Native lands, officials offered annual payments, or annuities. This article traces annuities’ material evolution from payments in goods to high-powered money—especially specie—and their financial evolution from straightforward congressional outlays to interest accrued on investments held in trust. Annuities originated as devices that could permit territorial expansion within considerable military-fiscal constraints. But once in use, they became potent instruments of federal power, shoring up officials’ capacity to intrude on Native economies, wrench further territorial transfers, and channel Indigenous wealth as capital for the very infrastructural projects that spread US settlement. Overall, annuities and the trust funds into which they evolved anchored a strategy of dispossession I call fiduciary colonialism: a mode of territorial acquisition and population management carried out through the expansion of administrative control over Native peoples’ wealth. In the face of federal claims to financial superiority, Indigenous peoples did not wither into wardship. Rather, they engaged trusteeship with their own futures in mind, applying annuities and trusts toward social institutions that would allow their nations to survive the ordeal of dispossession.

Using Randomized Controlled Trials to Improve the Scientific Process

Conducting randomized controlled trials on alternative strategies for conducting social and behavioral science may increase the quality of scientific findings.

Author(s)
J. Suls, A.J. Rothman and K.W. Davidson
Journal
American Psychologist
Citation
Suls, J., Rothman, A. J., & Davidson, K. W. (2022). Now is the time to assess the effects of open science practices with randomized control trials. American Psychologist, 77(3), 467–475. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000871 Copy
Abstract

We issue a call for the design and conduct of experimental trials to test the effects of researchers’ adoption of Open Science (OS) research practices. OS emerged to address lapses in the transparency, quality, integrity, and reproducibility of research by proposing that investigators institute practices, such as preregistering study hypotheses, procedures, and statistical analyses, before launching their research. These practices have been greeted with enthusiasm by some parts of the scientific community, but empirical evidence of their effects relies mainly on observational studies; furthermore, questions remain about the time and effort required by these practices and their ultimate benefit to science. To assess the outcomes of OS research practices, we propose they be viewed as behavioral interventions for scientists and tested in randomized controlled trials (RCTs), to identify potential benefits and (unintended) harms. As this is a call to action rather than an action plan per se, we sketch out four potential trial designs to encourage further deliberation and planning. Experimental tests to document the outcomes of OS practices can provide evidence to optimize how scientists, funders, policymakers, and institutions utilize these strategies to advance scientific practice.

Documenting Scientific Collaboration

A conservation initiative in northwest British Columbia to protect salmon health illustrates the challenges and opportunities of scientific collaboration.

Author(s)
Tom Özden-Schilling
Journal
American Anthropologist
Citation
Özden-Schilling, Tom. “Promising Resilience: Systems and Survival after Forestry's Ends.” American Anthropologist 124, no. 1 (2022): 64–76. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13678 Copy
Abstract

Ecologists, social scientists, and policymakers alike define “resilience” as the properties that allow complex systems to function in the wake of sudden shocks. While proponents treat these properties as empirical qualities that can be engineered into existence, critics have largely treated government-organized attempts to do so as consistent with the dismantling of the welfare state. This article offers an ethnographic account of a conservation policy initiative in northwest British Columbia designed to generate consensus-based quantitative indicators on salmon health. I examine how workshop organizers, emboldened by provocative metaphors of survival and systematicity, mobilize resilience discourse as a platform for social analysis, and urge other researchers to envision how their own work might allow them to transcend institutional attachments altogether. Resilience-based initiatives have wrought profound changes in experts’ everyday lives, in part by encouraging precariously employed researchers to reimagine their relationships to shrinking government institutions. In addition to naming an emergent political logic for legitimating downsizing and other organizational responses to disasters, I argue that resilience discourse provides the experts entrusted with designing these responses with new grammars for imagining the future viability of their own expertise.

The Effect of Trade Access on Social Conflict

The abandonment of China’s Grand Canal in 1826 caused a 117 percent increase in conflict in counties with canal access, relative to counties without access.

Author(s)
Yiming Cao and Shuo Chen
Journal
American Economic Review
Citation
Cao, Yiming, and Shuo Chen. "Rebel on the Canal: Disrupted Trade Access and Social Conflict in China, 1650–1911." American Economic Review 112, no. 5 (May 2022): 1555–90. Copy
Abstract

This paper examines the effects of the abandonment of China's Grand Canal—the world's largest and oldest artificial waterway—which served as a disruption to regional trade access. Using an original dataset covering 575 counties over 262 years, we show that the canal's abandonment contributed to the social turmoil that engulfed North China in the nineteenth century. Counties along the canal experienced an additional 117 percent increase in rebelliousness after the canal's closure relative to their non-canal counterparts. Our findings highlight the important role that continued access to trade routes plays in reducing conflict.

The Effects of State Surveillance on Collective Action

The as-if-random assignment of Catholic “spy priests” to local communities in Communist Poland reveals that Poland’s comprehensive use of surveillance facilitated antiregime collective action and decreased sabotage.

Author(s)
Anselm Hager and Krzysztof Krakowski
Journal
American Political Science Review
Citation
Hager, Anselm, and Krzysztof Krakowski. "Does State Repression Spark Protests? Evidence from Secret Police Surveillance in Communist Poland." American Political Science Review 116, no. 2 (May 2022): 564–79. Copy
Abstract

Does physical surveillance hinder or foster antiregime resistance? A common view holds that surveillance prevents resistance by providing regimes with high-quality intelligence on dissident networks and by instilling fear in citizens. We contrast this view using formerly classified data from Communist Poland. We find that communities exposed to secret police officers were more likely to organize protests but also engaged in less sabotage. To ensure that the relationship is causal, we use an instrumental variable strategy, which exploits the exogenous assignment of Catholic “spy priests” to local communities. To trace the underlying mechanisms, we draw on qualitative interviews and archival sources. We document that Poland’s comprehensive use of surveillance created widespread anger as well as an incentive for citizens to reveal their true loyalties, thus facilitating antiregime collective action. Once on the streets, protesters refrained from sabotage to signal their political motivation to bystanders and authorities alike.

The Effects of Anti-Discrimination Lawsuits on Firm Diversity

Firms sued by the EEOC for discrimination increase the racial and gender diversity of their managerial employees, with larger gains at larger firms and firm headquarters.

Author(s)
Carly Knight, Frank Dobbin, and Alexandra Kalev
Journal
American Sociological Review
Citation
Knight, Carly, Frank Dobbin, and Alexandra Kalev. “Under the Radar: Visibility and the Effects of Discrimination Lawsuits in Small and Large Firms.” American Sociological Review 87, no. 2 (April 2022): 175–201. Copy
Abstract

Research on how discrimination lawsuits affect corporate diversity has yielded mixed results. Qualitative studies highlight the limited efficacy of lawsuits in the typical workplace, finding that litigation frequently elicits resistance and even retribution from employers. But quantitative studies find that lawsuits can increase workforce diversity. This article develops an account of managerial resistance and firm visibility to reconcile these divergent findings. First, we synthesize job autonomy and group conflict theories to account for resistance that occurs when dominant groups perceive non-dominant groups to be attempting to usurp managerial authority, in this case through litigation. Second, we integrate insights from organizational institutionalism, which suggests that highly visible firms seek to demonstrate compliance with legal and societal norms. Drawing on this theory, we predict that only large, visible firms will see increases in diversity following lawsuits, and, by the same token, that the most visible workplaces of those large firms, their headquarters, will see the greatest changes. We test our hypotheses with data on litigation and workforce composition from a diverse set of 632 firms that were sued by the EEOC between 1997 and 2006. This study shows that understanding the consequences of lawsuits across firms, and across organizations within them, is key to tackling workplace discrimination.

Estimating the Presence of Less Visible Populations

Bayesian estimates of population presence can enable the delivery of services to those who suffer from stigma, discrimination, and criminalization.

Author(s)
Ian Laga, Xiaoyue Niu, and Le Bao
Journal
Journal of the American Statistical Association
Citation
Laga, Ian, Xiaoyue Niu, and Le Bao. “Modeling the Marked Presence-Only Data: A Case Study of Estimating the Female Sex Worker Size in Malawi.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 117, no. 537 (2022): 27–37. https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.2021.1944873. Copy
Abstract

Certain subpopulations like female sex workers (FSW), men who have sex with men (MSM), and people who inject drugs (PWID) often have higher prevalence of HIV/AIDS and are difficult to map directly due to stigma, discrimination, and criminalization. Fine-scale mapping of those populations contributes to the progress toward reducing the inequalities and ending the AIDS epidemic. In 2016 and 2017, the PLACE surveys were conducted at 3290 venues in 20 out of the total 28 districts in Malawi to estimate the FSW sizes. These venues represent a presence-only dataset where, instead of knowing both where people live and do not live (presence–absence data), only information about visited locations is available. In this study, we develop a Bayesian model for presence-only data and utilize the PLACE data to estimate the FSW size and uncertainty interval at a 1.5×1.5-km resolution for all of Malawi. The estimates can also be aggregated to any desirable level (city/district/region) for implementing targeted HIV prevention and treatment programs in FSW communities, which have been successful in lowering the incidence of HIV and other sexually transmitted infections.